25 Fudge Flavors You’ve Never Heard Of… But Should Absolutely Try

Most people think fudge begins and ends with chocolate and peanut butter. That’s cute. At Touch of Fudge, we treat fudge like an art form, a science experiment, and a dare… all at the same time. When you have more than 200 small-batch flavors made by hand, you get the classics—plus a whole universe of creations no one saw coming.

If you’ve ever wondered what happens when creativity meets a mixing bowl, this list is your backstage pass. These are the flavors shoppers whisper about, crave at midnight, or buy “just to see what happens.”

Spoiler: What happens is delicious.

1. Smokey BBQ

It sounds wrong until it hits your tongue. Then it’s smoky, sweet, and weirdly perfect. A gateway flavor for the BBQ curious.

2. White BBQ Bacon

This one shouldn’t work. Yet it does. And once you try it, you won’t shut up about it.

3. “Hot” Chili Chocolate

Dark chocolate with a slow-building kick. The kind of fudge that challenges you and then wins.

4. Drunken Panda

Bourbon warmth meets fudge softness. Kentucky in a bite.

5. Bourbonade

Bright lemonade energy with a bourbon hug at the end. Unexpected in the best way.

6. Maple Bourbon Walnut

For people who like flavor layers you can practically count. Maple, bourbon, crunch… repeat.

7. Train Wreck!!!

Chaos, but gourmet chaos. Sweet, salty, butterscotchy, crunchy… you’ll keep coming back just to figure it out.

8. Panda

Smooth, dark, and quietly confident. The introvert of the fudge world.

9. Mackenzie’s Mess

A flavor that looks wild, tastes wilder, and somehow feels intentional. Like a beautiful accident.

10. Tiger’s Butter

A peanut butter and white chocolate swirl with enough personality to have its own fan club.

11. Elvis (Banana + Peanut Butter)

If comfort food had a greatest hits album, this would be track one.

12. Monkey’s Butt

Don’t let the name fool you—this banana-chocolate combo goes down easy.

13. All-Mon Joy

A tropical take on nostalgia. Coconut lovers, this one’s your moment.

14. Not-A-Snickers

Everything you want from the candy aisle without any of the wrapper guilt.

15. SKI Fudge

Inspired by the citrus soda that Kentuckians swear is superior to all others. One bite and you’ll understand why.

16. OMG Orange!!!

So bright and citrusy it practically high-fives your taste buds.

17. Cosmic Grape

Your childhood candy memories called. They want you to buy this.

18. Bubble Gum

Will it bring out your inner kid? Yes. Will you care? No.

19. Candy Corn

Polarizing in Halloween form. Shockingly delightful in fudge form.

20. Unicorn

Magical, colorful, and unapologetically fun. A flavor that feels like a celebration.

21. Sparkle-Licious

A party flavor that tastes as good as it looks. Bring it to birthdays and watch what happens.

22. Dawn at the Downs

Rich, layered, and unmistakably Kentucky. Sip-your-coffee-while-eating-it energy.

23. Pina Colada

One bite and you’re mentally on a beach. No luggage required.

24. Peanut Butter & Green Apple

The tart-sweet apple cuts through the peanut butter in the most addictive way. An underdog that steals the show.

25. Tiger’s Butter (again?)

Yes. Because the people who try it once usually go back for round two.

Why These Flavors Hit Different

Touch of Fudge doesn’t follow traditional fudge rules.
We don’t load our batches with heavy condensed milk or 16 cups of sugar. We rely on technique, quality ingredients, and a small-batch process that consistently delivers smooth texture and big flavor. And because every batch is hand-made, you get color variations, personality, and character in every square.

In short: this isn’t mass-produced fudge. It’s craft fudge.

Ready to Taste Something New?

If your usual chocolate or peanut butter routine feels a little predictable, this list is your invitation to explore. Whether you’re buying for yourself or gifting someone who loves bold flavors, these 25 are the best way to start your adventure.